Skip to main content

Change to Ireland's abortion law

The Irish government is finally set to act. The New York Times and many other media outlets report that  Irish government officials are proposing to move from a total ban on abortion to one in which women can have an abortion "in cases where there is a real and substantial risk to a woman's life-- as distinct from her health" (New York Times).

I have written several times about what's going on in Ireland; to read, click on one or more of the 'labels' at the bottom of this post.

Ireland's debate over abortion demonstrates three things:

First, it demonstrates the power of the individual story to affect opinion and spur action. The move to (slightly) liberalize Ireland's total ban on abortion has been mandated since 1992 by the Irish Supreme Court and since 2010 by the European Court of Human Rights. The Irish government only got moving, however, after the tragic 2012 death of Dr. Savita Halappanaver, who died after suffering a miscarriage. Doctors in an Irish hospital refused to hasten the end of the miscarriage because the fetus was still alive (though inevitably dying). As a result of the delay in action, Dr. Halappanavar died from septicemia.

Second, it demonstrates the power of the Catholic Church and Catholic culture to resist change on abortion. For people who are pro-choice, the proposed legal change is a victory, considering the political and cultural conditions in Ireland, but only a victory of sorts, given how narrow the exception to a total ban is.  In the United States, pro-life activists can only dream of a time when American law would allow abortions only in cases of serious physical risks to a pregnant woman's life.

Third, it demonstrates that, regardless of time, place, or culture, many women want to have abortions. Ireland is often held up as a model pro-life country by activists. I can't recall where I saw it, but I watched a video of an American giving a speech in Ireland and telling his audience how wonderful Ireland was, given that no abortions take place there.

That speaker got it wrong. Abortions are likely taking place in Ireland, illegally, some safely (in the doctor's offices of the wealthy) and many more unsafely. Furthermore, there may be no abortions openly taking place in Ireland, but many Irish women are having abortions, in the United Kingdom, where they travel to have them, if they can afford it. The option for women (especially women of means) to escape the island and have a safe abortion in the UK serves as a kind of political pressure valve that allows the Irish government to keep an extremely restrictive ban on abortion in place with fewer political consequences, and preserve the fiction of Ireland as abortion free.

Links:

Article in The New York Times (December 18, 2012): Irish Government Set to Allow Abortion in Rare Cases


Article in The Christian Science Monitor (December 18, 2012): Ireland announces abortion law reforms, leaving no one satisfied

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The irony of the inquiry into Dr. Halappanavar's death

The Associated Press (via  The Washington Post ) reports that the composition of the panel that is investigating Dr. Savita Halappanavar's death in Ireland has changed: Prime Minister Enda Kenny told lawmakers he hoped the move — barely 24 hours after Ireland unveiled the seven-member panel — would allow the woman’s widower to support the probe into why Savita Halappanavar, a 31-year-old Indian dentist, died Oct. 28 while hospitalized in Galway.   Kenny’s U-turn came hours after her husband, Praveen Halappanavar, said he would refuse to talk to the investigators and would not consent to their viewing his wife’s medical records because three of the Galway hospital’s senior doctors had been appointed as investigators. Kenny said that the three doctors would be replaced by other officials “who have no connection at all with University Hospital Galway. In that sense the investigation will be completely and utterly independent.”   This makes sense. Why conduct an inquiry at all

Planned Parenthood and mammograms

Pro-life groups like Live Action love to charge Planned Parenthood with lying when it comes to whether the organization provides women with mammograms. Does Planned Parenthood provide mammograms? The literal answer appears to be "no," they do not. That being said, Planned Parenthood provides a) many breast exams a year (according to The Hill , 750,000), and b) referrals to organizations that do provide mammograms, much like many basic health care organizations. As with negative political advertising, then, the activists attacking Planned Parenthood are indulging in myopia, which allows them to focus on something that is literally true while failing to see the bigger and more relevant picture. The larger and more relevant picture in this case is that Planned Parenthood provides, among other preventative and primary care, access to breast exams and mammograms for women. If those women are poor and in areas (like in rural Texas) where Planned Parenthood is one of the only p